The opening of Parramatta’s new, controversial Powerhouse has, seemingly, confirmed a lot of people’s prejudices about the history of the old Museum of Applied Arts and Sciences, its removal to central (not really western) Sydney and “its eye-watering price tag – $915m, in an era of funding precarity for the arts”, according to The Guardian. While The Australian continued the Powerhouse Museum Alliance campaign to stay in Ultimo and firmly remain a museum, The Sydney Morning Herald kept up a splendid stream of positive articles such as “a $1b instrument of joy anyone can play” (were they sponsors?), and The Conversation peered through rose-tinted specs and saw only “So far, so good“.

Personally, I couldn’t resist the formerly unknown website, the Yellowbelly Press which summed things up: “Both a Herculean feat and a Sisyphusian task rolled into one”.

And then I ran into The Hon Don Harwin, NSW State Arts Minister from 2017 to 2021, responsible for commissioning the Parra Powerhouse (and the Art Gallery’s Sydney Modern and the Walsh Bay redevelopment), appointing Lisa Havilah to create it and establishing the budget to build it from COVID Recovery funds. Why has no one interviewed him, I wonder? For when I suggested that the stood-aside Havilah had been smart to get the current Minister Graham to keep tipping more money in, he assured me that Graham had actually cut funding while Havilah had simply done the job he’d appointed her to do.

One might well argue that it’s an unfortunate tendency of politicians’ to prefer arts infrastructure that they can open and admire to well-funded artists making work that challenges.

But, given that eye-watering price tag, have we got content that challenges inside a building that undoubtedly illuminates the Parramatta riverside landscape – walking distance from trains and ferries – and which now, thanks to its environmentally friendly white exoskeleton proudly bears the soubriquet, The Milkcrate?

In answering that, there’s a problem that no commentators have bothered to mention, which is that the content is so large, disparate and complex that the half day’s tour that journos got couldn’t possibly allow time to appreciate it. And, while numbers are reportedly impressive for the 23 day festival that’s opening the buildings – yes there are two – what chance that people will make repeated journeys to Parramatta in order to get around all five of the Museum’s current shows? And, how will they get enough information to choose the one/s relevant to their interests?

For, information, even inside the shows, is absolutely minimalist.

For Indigenous interest, for instance, one climbs to the top of one crate to find a vast, almost empty space. Weirdly, it’s called Overflow. And, yes, there is water in the middle of the space and you may (or probably not) notice that it rises and falls minimally with the Paramatta River tides – visible like much of Parramatta, outside. And you can paddle in it. But will you then pay attention to Ivan Sen’s gorgeous film of water stories from the local Barramadagal Community; the Gamay Rangers from Botany Bay; the Goondee Aboriginal Museum and Keeping Place in Lightning Ridge; the Jagun Alliance on Bundjalung Country around Lismore; the Joonga Land and Water Aboriginal Land Corporation on Yuin Country around Narooma; Moogalin Performing Arts (oddly) representing Brewarrina and its historic fish traps; and the Gumbaynggirr Naru Aboriginal Corporation on the mid-North Coast?

Very NSW; saltwater, freshwater – the eternal clash. Flood mitigation, sustainable and commercial fishing, water monitoring, species protection, language association and cultural water rights (versus cotton!) all get a mention behind Sen’s beautiful images. Good to think about them.

The Indigenous also goes into space, as in the Task Eternal exhibition, which showcases groundbreaking Australian industry collaborations and technological achievements, starting of course with the bumerang – as they’ve always spelled it in Parramatta. The British Museum has supplied the genuinely-sourced object dating from 1870. Maybe it inspired Leonardo da Vinci – because four of his fabulous drawings imagining Man developing flight from birds have also come from Europe. Aussie Lawrence Hargrave certainly picked up an idea or two from the boomerang, but the exhibition seems more interested in space suits, TV series, a crazy wooden Australian satellite and a room full of incomprehensible aero-engines. Not so crazy, an electronic map of near-space showing the terrifying density of satellites whizzing around was a show-stopper. At the top you can pay extra for a Turrell experience, but, back at the bottom you come full circle to encounter First Nations Sky Country in the forms of Guynbi Ganambarr’s incised TV satellite dishes and Naminapu Maymaru-White’s Milky Way larrikitj poles.

Oh, and five aeroplanes hang precariously on top of each other for those wanting to recapture some Ultimo memories.

All a bit random, you might think – but a slower tour might have provoked more thought.

Which was also my response to The Dark, an unpromising name for the kids’ special space. Aren’t a few kids frightened of the dark??? Well, it’s not that dark inside a tunnel that goes on and on and contains a playground, a Larrakia Songline to mother, and a tonne of stuff from the MAAS collection such as displays of shining minerals and precious stones captioned with stories of the people who discovered them, and eccentricities such as mechanical birds that sing when a button is pressed and a transparent woman whose body parts light up on command.

The Mall passed me by – apart from marvelling that the world’s first shopping mall courtesy of Westfield turned up in Blacktown, I have to admit that I resist such things whenever I can find a boutique bakery or butcher or organic market. But in the age of David Jones’s collapse, perhaps we do need to think about how and why we shop a bit more.

Finally Es Devlin and another odd title, The Turning. Apparently it reflects our times as The Great Turning. Backwards, sideways??? The times don’t seem to be heading anywhere I want them to go! And Ms Devlin appears to think along the same lines though much more exotically as a “visionary” designer. And she thinks big, including the collective imagination, the whole of Earth’s biodiversity and “the profound ability of places to house memories”. Fortunately, the exhibition is primarily informed by Sydney, its ecologies, communities and mixed identities – such as 244 local species that are threatened – as she attempts to persuade us that habitat needs to find a way into everyday conversations. Somehow she links the branching of rivers and trees with shape of human lungs, and then throws us into a mirror maze that is intended to reflect our contemporary narcissism, “the self searching endlessly across reflective surfaces hoping to find wholeness”. It’s actually quite a bit more fun than that! As was the opportunity to sit opposite a stranger and draw their face on an endless sheet of paper – a perfect counter to my natural narcissism!

Summing up, I’m sure there are valid visits to The Milkcrate for all enquiring minds, and, in terms of contemporary museology, there’s much to marvel at in a performative aspect to many things – using film and video, sound and light and technology to cheer up the excessive amount of grey concrete that surrounds the exhibitions. Could we have had more texts as well? But there are lots of chairs looking out at Parramatta to give one pause for thought, and little niche feed-stations about. It didn’t feel like the entertainment centre that critics predicted – the only large unoccupied space being a restaurant on the ground-floor where flooding is possible – all the exhibitions safely up higher.

Give Sysiphus a roll!

Url: